Skip to content
We’ve been buying from Island Furniture for about four years now.
From mattresses to Bed frames, Sofas, and Tv Stands & I have not been disappointed not once!
Read More Reviews At:
Google
1720 Dempster St, Mt Prospect, IL 60056
1720 Dempster St, Mt Prospect, IL 60056
About Us Contact Us Refund Policy Privacy Policy Your Privacy Choices

Consumer Choice

Filters

Filter

Refine

view all

Type

clear

Brand

Sub Brand

AR Availability

Color

Consumer Assembly

Material

Price

Product Theme

Product Video

Shade

Shipping

Style

Collection

clear
Product image Save up to 23% Save %
$99.20 - $184.94
$99.20 - $184.94
$99.20
$76.31 - $142.26
$76.31 - $142.26
$76.31

Bolanburg Counter Height Bar Stool

The beauty of this upholstered bar stool is something to savor. Designed to serve up comfort and flair, this backless bar stool entices with a sad...

View full details
$99.20 - $184.94
$99.20 - $184.94
$99.20
$76.31 - $142.26
$76.31 - $142.26
$76.31
Save up to 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$211.89
$211.89 - $211.89
$211.89
$162.99
$162.99 - $162.99
$162.99

Burkhaus Counter Height Barstool

Dressed to thrill, this counter height bar stool offers a high-design look at a down-to-earth price. Ultra-sleek lines are accentuated with a dark...

View full details
$211.89
$211.89 - $211.89
$211.89
$162.99
$162.99 - $162.99
$162.99
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$225.36
$225.36 - $225.36
$225.36
$173.35
$173.35 - $173.35
$173.35

Caitbrook Counter Height Bar Stool

Bring a relaxed yet refined sense of good taste to a space with this upholstered swivel bar stool. The sturdy wood frame with contoured backrest i...

View full details
$225.36
$225.36 - $225.36
$225.36
$173.35
$173.35 - $173.35
$173.35
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$225.36
$225.36 - $225.36
$225.36
$173.35
$173.35 - $173.35
$173.35

Caitbrook Bar Height Bar Stool

Bring a relaxed yet refined sense of good taste to a space with this upholstered swivel bar stool. The sturdy wood frame with contoured backrest i...

View full details
$225.36
$225.36 - $225.36
$225.36
$173.35
$173.35 - $173.35
$173.35
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$127.37
$127.37 - $127.37
$127.37
$97.98
$97.98 - $97.98
$97.98

Gesthaven Counter Height Barstool

Complement your home’s simply relaxed sensibility with this counter height bar stool. A charming green hue offers a chic contrast to the natural...

View full details
$127.37
$127.37 - $127.37
$127.37
$97.98
$97.98 - $97.98
$97.98
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$286.61
$286.61 - $286.61
$286.61
$220.47
$220.47 - $220.47
$220.47

Haddigan Bar Stool Set

Modern sophistication, beautifully served. This bar stool raises the bar with a cool, rake back design with staggered rungs for added interest. Da...

View full details
$286.61
$286.61 - $286.61
$286.61
$220.47
$220.47 - $220.47
$220.47
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$143.31
$143.31 - $143.31
$143.31
$110.24
$110.24 - $110.24
$110.24

Haddigan Counter Height Bar Stool

Modern sophistication, beautifully served. This bar stool raises the bar with a cool, rake back design with staggered rungs for added interest. Da...

View full details
$143.31
$143.31 - $143.31
$143.31
$110.24
$110.24 - $110.24
$110.24
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$127.37
$127.37 - $127.37
$127.37
$97.98
$97.98 - $97.98
$97.98

Wildenauer Counter Height Barstool

This counter height bar stool dresses up your favorite farmhouse motifs with modern flair. A contoured butcher-block style seat keeps you comforta...

View full details
$127.37
$127.37 - $127.37
$127.37
$97.98
$97.98 - $97.98
$97.98
Save 23% Save %
Valebeck Counter Height Dining Set image
Save up to 23% Save %
$1,294.63 - $1,593.48
$1,294.63 - $1,593.48
$1,294.63
$995.87 - $1,225.75
$995.87 - $1,225.75
$995.87

Valebeck Counter Height Dining Set

This 5-piece dining set serves up the best in rustic farmhouse living. The counter height table's two-done distressed finish pairs a brown tableto...

View full details
$1,294.63 - $1,593.48
$1,294.63 - $1,593.48
$1,294.63
$995.87 - $1,225.75
$995.87 - $1,225.75
$995.87
Save up to 23% Save %
Valebeck Counter Height Barstool image
Save 23% Save %
$156.78
$156.78 - $156.78
$156.78
$120.60
$120.60 - $120.60
$120.60

Valebeck Counter Height Barstool

This counter height bar stool serves up the best in cottage styling. Its contoured seat keeps you comfortable while chatting over coffee and bante...

View full details
$156.78
$156.78 - $156.78
$156.78
$120.60
$120.60 - $120.60
$120.60
Save 23% Save %
Valebeck Bar Height Bar Stool image
Save 23% Save %
$242.52
$242.52 - $242.52
$242.52
$186.55
$186.55 - $186.55
$186.55

Valebeck Bar Height Bar Stool

A touch of rustic-industrial style is such a fashion-forward choice, and this barstool doesn’t disappoint. Set this tall barstool by the kitchen b...

View full details
$242.52
$242.52 - $242.52
$242.52
$186.55
$186.55 - $186.55
$186.55
Save 23% Save %
Tyler Creek Counter Height Bar Stool image
Save 23% Save %
$184.94
$184.94 - $184.94
$184.94
$142.26
$142.26 - $142.26
$142.26

Tyler Creek Counter Height Bar Stool

Invite your family into the heart of your home with this upholstered bar stool. Its framed back and tapered legs, in a beautifully textured black ...

View full details
$184.94
$184.94 - $184.94
$184.94
$142.26
$142.26 - $142.26
$142.26
Save 23% Save %
Tyler Creek Bar Stool Set image
Save 23% Save %
$369.89
$369.89 - $369.89
$369.89
$284.53
$284.53 - $284.53
$284.53

Tyler Creek Bar Stool Set

Invite your family into the heart of your home with this upholstered bar stool. Its framed back and tapered legs, in a beautifully textured black ...

View full details
$369.89
$369.89 - $369.89
$369.89
$284.53
$284.53 - $284.53
$284.53
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$450.71
$450.71 - $450.71
$450.71
$346.70
$346.70 - $346.70
$346.70

Tallenger Bar Stool Set

This striking barstool set invites you to take contemporary modern style for a spin. Comfortably cushioned seat, self-returning swivel and contour...

View full details
$450.71
$450.71 - $450.71
$450.71
$346.70
$346.70 - $346.70
$346.70
Save 23% Save %
Product image
Save up to 23% Save %
$85.74 - $127.37
$85.74 - $127.37
$85.74
$65.95 - $97.98
$65.95 - $97.98
$65.95

Skempton Counter Height Bar Stool

This upholstered bar stool invites you to raise the bar on small space living. An inspired choice for coastal chic or modern farmhouse settings, t...

View full details
$85.74 - $127.37
$85.74 - $127.37
$85.74
$65.95 - $97.98
$65.95 - $97.98
$65.95
Save up to 23% Save %
Robbinsdale Counter Height Barstool image
Save 23% Save %
$156.78
$156.78 - $156.78
$156.78
$120.60
$120.60 - $120.60
$120.60

Robbinsdale Counter Height Barstool

This counter height bar stool is sure to impress come mealtime. With its white finish and light gray upholstery, farmhouse-style seating has never...

View full details
$156.78
$156.78 - $156.78
$156.78
$120.60
$120.60 - $120.60
$120.60
Save 23% Save %
Ralene Counter Height Bar Stool image
Save 23% Save %
$143.31
$143.31 - $143.31
$143.31
$110.24
$110.24 - $110.24
$110.24

Ralene Counter Height Bar Stool

Sleek lines and comfortable cushioning combine to make this upholstered bar stool the favorite seat at the table. Its traditional shaker design is...

View full details
$143.31
$143.31 - $143.31
$143.31
$110.24
$110.24 - $110.24
$110.24
Save 23% Save %
Pinnadel Counter Height Bar Stool image
Save 23% Save %
$242.52
$242.52 - $242.52
$242.52
$186.55
$186.55 - $186.55
$186.55

Pinnadel Counter Height Bar Stool

This striking counter height bar stool serves a sense of refinement without all the formality. A 360-degree spin element keeps you in the flow of ...

View full details
$242.52
$242.52 - $242.52
$242.52
$186.55
$186.55 - $186.55
$186.55
Save 23% Save %
Pinnadel Bar Height Bar Stool image
Save 23% Save %
$242.52
$242.52 - $242.52
$242.52
$186.55
$186.55 - $186.55
$186.55

Pinnadel Bar Height Bar Stool

This pub height bar stool serves a sense of refinement without all the formality. A 360-degree spin element keeps you in the flow of conversation,...

View full details
$242.52
$242.52 - $242.52
$242.52
$186.55
$186.55 - $186.55
$186.55
Save 23% Save %
Moriville Counter Height Bar Stool image
Save 23% Save %
$156.78
$156.78 - $156.78
$156.78
$120.60
$120.60 - $120.60
$120.60

Moriville Counter Height Bar Stool

This upholstered bar stool might be simple at first sight, but a closer look reveals beauty in the details. With a distressed nutmeg finish, antiq...

View full details
$156.78
$156.78 - $156.78
$156.78
$120.60
$120.60 - $120.60
$120.60
Save 23% Save %
Moriville Bar Stool Set image
Save 23% Save %
$313.56
$313.56 - $313.56
$313.56
$241.20
$241.20 - $241.20
$241.20

Moriville Bar Stool Set

This upholstered bar stool might be simple at first sight, but a closer look reveals beauty in the details. With a distressed nutmeg finish, antiq...

View full details
$313.56
$313.56 - $313.56
$313.56
$241.20
$241.20 - $241.20
$241.20
Save 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$1,135.37 - $1,475.89
$1,135.37 - $1,475.89
$1,135.37
$873.36 - $1,135.30
$873.36 - $1,135.30
$873.36

Lyncott Dining Room Set

A refreshed take on retro aesthetics. This dining package adds an air of playful simplicity to your dining space, capturing the architectural lang...

View full details
$1,135.37 - $1,475.89
$1,135.37 - $1,475.89
$1,135.37
$873.36 - $1,135.30
$873.36 - $1,135.30
$873.36
Save up to 23% Save %
Product image
Save 23% Save %
$127.37
$127.37 - $127.37
$127.37
$97.98
$97.98 - $97.98
$97.98

Lyncott Counter Height Bar Stool

A refreshed take on retro aesthetics. This upholstered bar stool adds an air of playful simplicity to your dining space, capturing the architectur...

View full details
$127.37
$127.37 - $127.37
$127.37
$97.98
$97.98 - $97.98
$97.98
Save 23% Save %

Consumer Choice — Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Consumer Choice collection?

Consumer Choice gathers the pieces our customers love most at island furniture and more — the styles that get chosen, reviewed well, and reordered again and again. Think of it as a shortcut to our proven favorites.

Why should I shop Consumer Choice?

If you want something dependable without combing through the entire catalog, this is a great place to start — it's a curated shortlist of best-sellers from Ashley Furniture that have already won people over.

Do you deliver Consumer Choice items?

Yes. We deliver throughout our local service area — see our shipping & delivery policy for timelines and coverage, or contact us for a quote.

Can I finance a Consumer Choice purchase?

Yes. We offer financing options on qualifying purchases, often with promotional low- or no-interest plans.

Can I see these items in person?

Many of our most popular pieces are on display in the showroom, though the floor selection rotates. Please contact us to confirm a specific item is available to view before you visit.

What if my item arrives damaged?

Inspect it at delivery, note any damage on the paperwork, take photos, and contact us right away. We'll arrange a repair, replacement, or return under our return policy.

Liquid error (snippets/dovr-body-scripts line 2): Could not find asset snippets/dovr-trust-bar.liquid Liquid error (snippets/dovr-body-scripts line 3): Could not find asset snippets/dovr-json-ld-schemas.liquid